Modelling the Modal Shift Effects of Converting a General Traffic Lane into a Dedicated Bus Lane
Abstract
This paper presents an analytical framework for evaluating the performance of dedicated bus lanes. It assumes that under a designated travel demand, the traffic volume on a corridor changes with the modal shifts. The modal shift affects the operations of both bus traffic and car traffic and eventually, an equilibrium bus share ratio that maximizes the performance of the corridor will be reached. Microsimulation modelling is employed to assess the traffic operations under various demand levels and bus share ratios. The results show that converting a general lane into a bus lane significantly reduces bus delay. For car traffic, the overall trend is that delay increases after converting a general lane to a bus lane. In addition, delay decreases with the increase of bus share ratio. Nevertheless, when bus share ratio reaches 0.6 (demand less than 10,000 passengers per hour, pph; or 0.8 when demand increases up to 14,000 pph), there is no significant difference in delay between the two scenarios. The identified bus share ratios have the potential to direct the development of bus lane warrants. Finally, this research recommends that the Transportation Demand Management (TDM) strategies shall be developed to stimulate the modal shifts towards the identified optimal bus share ratio.
References
Mesbah M, Sarvi M, Currie G, Saffarzadeh M. Policy-Making Tool for Optimization of Transit Priority Lanes in Urban Network. Transportation Research Record. 2010;2197: 54-62.
Idris AO, Habib KMN, Shalaby A. Dissecting the Role of Transit Service Attributes in Attracting Commuters: Lessons from a Comprehensive Revealed Preference-Stated Preference Study on Commuting Mode-Switching Behavior in Toronto, Ontario, Canada. Transportation Research Record. 2014;2415: 107-117.
Idris AO, Habib KMN, Shalaby A. An Investigation on the Performances of Mode Shift Models in Transit
Ridership Forecasting. Transportation Research Part A. 2015;78: 551-565.
Anwar AM, Yang J. Examining the Effects of Transport Policy on Modal Shift from Private Car to Public Bus. Procedia Engineering. 2017;180: 1413-1422.
Fearnley N, Flugel S, Killi M, et al. Triggers of Urban Passenger Mode Shift – State of the Art and Model Evidence. Transportation Research Procedia. 2017;26: 62-80.
Rahman ML, Baker D. Modelling Induced Mode Switch Behaviour in Bangladesh: A Multinomial Logistic Regression Approach. Transport Policy. 2018;71: 81-91.
Sheffi Y. A Simple Equilibrium Analysis of Designating a Freeway Lane to Exclusive Bus Use. Transportation Research Record. 1981;775: 7-11.
Mogridge MJH. The Self-defeating Nature of Urban Road Capacity Policy. Transport Policy. 1997;4(1): 5-23.
Hounsell N, McDonald M. Evaluation of Bus Lanes. Transport and Road Research Laboratory, U.K. Report Number: 87, 1988.
Shalaby S, Soberman M. Effect of With Flow Bus Lanes on Bus Travel Times. Transportation Research Record. 1994;1433: 25-30.
St. Jacques K, Levinson H. Operational Analysis of Bus Lanes on Arterials. Transportation Research Board, Transit Cooperative Research Program 26, Washington, D.C., 1997.
Gibson J, Munizaga MA, Schneider C, Tirachini A. Estimating the Bus User Time Benefits of Implementing a Median Busway: Methodology and Case Study. Transportation Research Part A. 2016;84(5): 72-82.
Truong LT, Currie G, Sarvi M. Analytical and Simulation Approaches to Understand Combined Effects of Transit Signal Priority and Road-Space Priority Measures. Transportation Research Part C. 2017;74: 275-295.
Yao J, Cheng Z, Shi F, An S, Wang J. Evaluation of Exclusive Bus Lanes in a Tri-Modal Road Network Incorporating Carpooling Behavior. Transport Policy. 2018;68: 130-141.
Currie G, Sarvi M, Young, B. A New Approach to Evaluating On-Road Public Transport Priority Projects: Balancing the Demand for Limited Road-Space. Transportation. 2007;34(4): 413-428.
Gan A, Yue H, Ubaka I, Zhao F. Development of Operational Performance and Decision Models for Arterial Bus Lanes. Transportation Research Record. 2003;1858: 18-31.
Tsamboulas D. Ex-Ante Evaluation of Exclusive Bus Lanes Implementation. Journal of Public Transportation. 2006;9(3): 201-217.
Mesbah M, Sarvi M, Currie, G. New Methodology for Optimizing Transit Priority at the Network Level. Transportation Research Record. 2008;2089: 93-100.
Li S, Ju Y. Evaluation of Bus-exclusive Lanes. IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transport System. 2009;10(2): 236-245.
Yao J, Shi F, Zhou Z, Qin J. Combinatorial Optimization of Exclusive Bus Lanes and Bus Frequencies in Multi-Modal Transportation Network. Journal of Transportation Engineering. 2012;138(12): 1422-1429.
Zhao J, Zhou X. Improving the Operational Efficiency of Buses with Dynamic Use of Exclusive Bus Lane at Isolated Intersections. IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems. 2019;20(2): 642-653.
Shalaby A. Simulating Performance Impacts of Bus Lanes and Supporting Measures. Journal of Transportation Engineering. 1999;125(5): 390-397.
Waterson BJ, Rajbhandari B, Hounsell NB. Simulating the Impacts of Strong Bus Priority Measures. Journal of Transportation Engineering. 2003;129(6): 642-647.
Arasan VT, Vedagiri P. Microsimulation Study of the Effect of Exclusive Bus Lanes on Heterogeneous Traffic Flow. Journal of Urban Planning and Development. 2010;136(1): 50-58.
Zhu L, Yu L, Chen X, Guo J. Simulated Analysis of Exclusive Bus Lanes on Expressways: Case Study in Beijing, China. Journal of Public Transportation. 2012;15(4): 111-128.
Tu TV, Sano K, Nguyen CY, Tan DT. Comparative Analysis of Bus Lane Operations in Urban Roads using Microscopic Traffic Simulation. Asian Transport Studies. 2013;2(3): 269-283.
Ben-Dor G, Ben-Elia E, Benenson I. Assessing the Impacts of Dedicated Bus Lanes on Urban Traffic Congestion and Modal Split with an Agent-Based Model. Procedia Computer Science. 2018;130: 824-829.
Ben-Akiva M, Lerman S. Discrete Choice Analysis: Theory and Application to Travel Demand. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press; 1985.
Sheffi Y. Urban Transportation Networks: Equilibrium Analysis with Mathematical Programming. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall Inc.; 1985.
Sun H, Si B, Wu J. Combined Model for Flow Assignment and Mode Split in Two-Modes Traffic Network. Journal of Transportation Systems Engineering and Information Technology. 2008;8(4): 77-82.
Zuo Z, Yang G, Shao C. Modeling Modal Shift of Car Travelers to Buses Based on Public Transport Priority. Journal of Transportation Systems Engineering and Information Technology. 2011;12(1): 124-131.
Vedagipi P, Arasan V. Modelling Modal Shift Due to the Enhanced Level of Bus Service. Transport. 2009;24(2): 121-128.
Zuo Z, Yang G, Shao C. Modal Shift of Car Travelers to Buses Based on Bus Priority. Proceedings of 91st Annual Meeting of Transportation Research Board, Washington D.C.; 2012.
Wang Y, Wang Z, Li Z, Staley SR, Moore AT, Gao Y. Study of Modal Shifts to Bus Rapid Transit in Chinese Cities. Journal of Urban Planning and Development. 2013;139(1): 515-523.
Wang Y, Li L, Wang Z, Lv T, Wang L. Mode Shift Behavior Impacts from the Introduction of Metro Service: Case Study of Xi’an, China. Journal of Transportation Engineering. 2013;139(3): 216-225.
Yao J, Shi F, An S, Wang J. Evaluation of Exclusive Bus Lanes in a Bi-Modal Degradable Road Network. Transportation Research Part C. 2015;60: 35-16.
Zheng N, Dantsuji T, Wang P, Geroliminis N. Macroscopic Approach for Optimizing Road Space Allocation of Bus Lanes in Multimodal Urban Networks Through Simulation Analysis. Transportation Research Record. 2017;2651: 42-51.
Downs A. The Law of Peak-Hour Expressway Congestion. Traffic Quarterly. 1962;16(3): 393-409.
Mogridge M, Holden D, Bird J, Terzis G. The Downs-Thomson Paradox and the Transportation Planning Process. International Journal of Transportation Economics. 1987;14(3): 283-311.
Meneguzzer C. Review of Models Combining Traffic Assignment and Signal Control. Journal of Transportation Engineering. 1997;123(2): 148-155.
Gartner N, Al-Malik, M. Combined Model for Signal Control and Route Choice in Urban Traffic Networks. Transportation Research Record. 1996;1554: 27-35.
Wardrop JG. Some Theoretical Aspects of Road Traffic Research. Proceedings of Institution of Civil Engineers, Part II. 1952;1(2): 325-378.
Yang H, Yagar S. Traffic Assignment and Signal Control in Saturated Road Networks. Transportation Research Part A. 1995;29(2): 125-139.
Mazloumi E, Moridpour S, Mohsenian H. Delay Function for Signalized Intersections in Traffic Assignment Models. Journal of Urban Planning and Development. 2010;136(1): 67-74.
TRB. Highway Capacity Manual, Sixth Edition: A Guide for Multimodal Mobility Analysis. Washington, D.C.: The National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine; 2016.
Copyright (c) 2020 Guangchuan Yang, Daobin Wang, Xuesong Mao
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:
- Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (See The Effect of Open Access).
